Little Miss Rainbow vs. The Kraut
Terrence O'Flaherty -
San Francisco Chronicle
December 16
At the continued insistence
of that middle-aged imp, Jack Paar, his guest, Judy Garland delivered some
surprisingly unprofessional remarks about Marlene Dietrich, who recently
opened in London. Neither one of these living legends needs the publicity
of a feud, but if the lady Ernest Hemingway nicknamed "The Kraut" so chooses,
she could tear Little Miss Rainbow to shreds. Actually the one who
needs the publicity is Paar, whos show is Number 82 this year.
MIss Garland's voice is deteriorating
and it is dangerously close to becoming a caricature of herself.
Miss Dietrich never had one, but both performers are more successful in
lighting up a song than any popular stars of our time. I suspect
Miss Garland's glass house is too vulnerable to attack for her to throw
the first stone in any direction. Her comments on Miss Dietrich's
entrance to a party clutching a huge record were quite another matter and
very charming.
Daily Variety
December 14
For the Anglophiles it must
have been a jolly evening. The lip readers must have enjoyed it,
too. For those who had trouble cutting through the thick accents
it was pretty dreary. Saving grace for them, however, must have been
the participation , in song and dialog, of Judy Garland. As for Jack
Paar, like he said, "It's impossible for you not to like me. I don't
do anything." and truer words he never spoke.
In an anecdotal exchange,
Judy told a story on Marlene Dietrich that was a little catty. Miss
Garland did say she didn't want to be too harsh with Marlene. Most
of the dialog between Paar and the singer was both disjointed and unrevealing
of her experiences abroad. Her singing voice was both tremulous and
blatant. The thunderous applause must have been a demonstration of
affection for Miss Garland. Paar should give Miss Dietrich equal
time to answer her detractor (a promotion natural)
Philadelphia Inquirer
Henry Harris
December 14
Judy Garland's voice was
shrilly off-key during the two doleful songs she sang on Friday's filmed
in London JACK PAAR PROGRAM. But - despite a certain strangeness
of manner - she proved a most entertaining conversationalist.
How did she feel about being
"a living legend?" "It's lonesome, everyone thinks of you as the
Statue of Liberty who doesn't breathe."
She told an amusing story
about a chauffeur's failure to let her make a proper entrance at a posh
affair, so that she had to circle the block and repeat the business of
making a gracious gestures, and an even funnier one about Marlene
Dietrich's long, long-playing recored, consisting of nothing but idolatrous
audiences' applause. "Noel Coward said, "I hope there isn't another
side to this," Judy recalled. "There WAS!" |